On Thu, 17 Jan 2008 19:12:43 -0500, Paul <> wrote:
> wrote:
>> I finally had time to put the CPU back on the MB. Previously I was
>> getting "overclocked" messages from the BIOS even though it was
>> underclocked. Then it would boot normally and run for a while before
>> freezing up.
>>
>> Now that the CPU was removed and then reinstalled it doesn't work at
>> all. When I hit the power button the fans all turn for about three
>> seconds, and then it shuts off. No beeps, no nothing. It looks to me
>> like a cooling issue, as if the the heatsink isn't making good contact
>> or something. Or maybe the chip's completely shot from static or
>> something from when it was off the MB. What do you think?
>
>The board has CPU overheat protection, so it could be thermal. Did
>you get paste on the pins ? Be careful, as you can chip the edges
>of the die - that is what those rubber pads are for on the corners,
>to help protect the silicon die from chipping on the edges.
>
> Paul
I fixed it. I had ordered a shim from frozenCPU.com to replace the
pads - it serves the same purpose. They sent me six of them. They
looked extremely thin, so I figured you stack them until you get to
the right thickness - why else would they send me six of them? lol -
so I started with two. Turns out just one of them is the perfect
thickness and two of them holds the heatsink off the die. Thank God
for built-in thermal protection. Do all boards have that nowadays?
Anyway the rig has been running stable at the proper clock speed for a
couple of hours now, and no warnings from the bios either. I'll have
to leave it on for 24 hours or so before I declare it fixed.
I can think of two possibilities, at this point, of what could have
been wrong with it:
1) I went to the arctic silver site to see their recommended way to
use the compound. They say do not get any compound anywhere except
the die, especially not on any lands. They explain that although the
grease is nonconductive, over time dust can migrate under there and
contaminate any excess grease and it can begin to get some electrical
properties such as capacitance - and that can cause the CPU to do
eratic things.
Well I bought this board and CPU together from Aberdeeninc, and they
mounted the CPU and heatsink and tested it before they shipped it. It
cost more that way, but I got a guaranteed working mobo and CPU. When
I pulled that heatsink off the CPU I could see that whoever assembled
it had gotten grease all over the place. So I cleaned it all off.
Maybe that was the problem.
2) Heat. When I had this apart I took the fan off the CPU and there
was a lot of dust gunked on the fins. I've seen much worse on
computers that were working fine. But this was a package deal, and
the supplied heatsink was probably just adequate - when completely
clean. So I cleaned the heatsink, and I added another fan to the
case.
Of the two possibilities I think heat is more likely, but I'll never
know for sure, at least not until the dust builds up on the heatsink
again.