I had the same problem just last week and did trouble shooting and parts
swapping just like you. In my situation it was the motherboard, and yes
I've never had a motherboard go bad. First time for everything I guess.
Works fine now. Good luck.
"phelper" <> wrote in message
news

...
>
>
> Computer has been working for about 10 to 11 months.
>
> This weekend, I went to turn it on, and I got an error saying
> something to the effect that I needed to insert a new boot medium, as
> if it couldn't find my hard drive. I didn't have time to mess with
> it, so I powered down.
>
> Came back a couple hours later, everything worked fine.
>
> The next morning, the computer wouldn't turn on. No power up, so the
> monitors wouldn't come on either. Took the cover off the case,
> powered up, everything was fine.
>
> Then today, again it won't power up. So I started troubleshooting.
>
> Power Supply? PC Power And Cooilng Silencer 470. Did the
> troubleshootiong routine, short out the green and black wire on the 24
> pin plug, and plug it in to the outlet. Powered up just fine by
> itself. Put another Power Supply in the computer just in case, and it
> wouldn't work. With both of them, sometimes when I'd hit the swich,
> the fan would spin for less than one revolution.
>
> Unplugged everything from the back of the case except the monitors (2
> of them, unplugged the usb, etc..). Took out the SB XFI. Wouldn't
> power up. Took out the memory. Wouldn't power up. Took out the
> video card. Wouldn't power up.
> Unplugged all my molex connectors. Wouldn't power up. Unplugged
> everything but the CPU cooler. Wouldn't power up. Took a switch from
> an older computer case, just for the possibility that the case swith
> was bad no dice.
>
> I've done all my 22 years of working with computer hardware has taught
> me. Now I'm at a loss. Is my mainboard dead? I've never, ever, ever
> had a motherboard die on me. I guess I could take the chip out and
> see if it would beep at me, but I hesitate to do so, since I hate
> dealing with thermal compound, and don't want to remove the waterblock
> (liquid cooled).
>
> Anyone have any suggestions? Thanks so much.
>
>
> Not sure that it matters, but the chip is an Athlon 64 4600. I don't
> suppose the other components matter, since the couple won't power up
> even after I remove them.