ATI vs ATI

Ati Radeon Sapphire 9800Pro 256Mb Ddr (euro335)
vs
Ati Radeon Hercules 9800Se 128Mb All-In-Wonder Ret (euro 240)

Who is the winner ??

Nr.1

Hercules is Se card! mean, only128bit mem(apposed to 256bit), 128mb vs
256mb, And Se is clocked slower than PRO.

"MaGiSteR" <> wrote in message
news:xuIWb.2287$...
> Ati Radeon Sapphire 9800Pro 256Mb Ddr (euro335)
> vs
> Ati Radeon Hercules 9800Se 128Mb All-In-Wonder Ret (euro 240)
>
> Who is the winner ??
>
>

MaGiSteR wrote:

> Ati Radeon Sapphire 9800Pro 256Mb Ddr (euro335)
> vs
> Ati Radeon Hercules 9800Se 128Mb All-In-Wonder Ret (euro 240)
>
> Who is the winner ??

Define "winner". The SE wins on price, the Pro wins on performance.

--
--John
Reply to jclarke at ae tee tee global dot net
(was jclarke at eye bee em dot net)

Dont forget that some 9800SE's can be turned into 9800Pro's - at least as
far as enabling the extra pipelines goes. Depends on the board you get -
theres a list on the net of boards that can have a 256-bit memory bus.

If its the right one - get the 9800SE and just softmod it to a 9800pro.

Kai

"MaGiSteR" <> wrote in message
news:xuIWb.2287$...
> Ati Radeon Sapphire 9800Pro 256Mb Ddr (euro335)
> vs
> Ati Radeon Hercules 9800Se 128Mb All-In-Wonder Ret (euro 240)
>
> Who is the winner ??
>
>

can't give you comparison, but I like my Gigabyte 9800Pro 256. clocking
around 395/395 w/o problem. got a deal on it for 300$ US right before XT
series came out.

--
Dave M
Etna, Maine USA
Radeon 9800Pro 256mb
P4 2.8 oc to 3.1


"MaGiSteR" <> wrote in message
news:xuIWb.2287$...
> Ati Radeon Sapphire 9800Pro 256Mb Ddr (euro335)
> vs
> Ati Radeon Hercules 9800Se 128Mb All-In-Wonder Ret (euro 240)
>
> Who is the winner ??
>
>

Asestar wrote:
> Nr.1
>
> Hercules is Se card! mean, only128bit mem(apposed to 256bit), 128mb vs
> 256mb, And Se is clocked slower than PRO.

No, it DOES have 256 bit mem, but only 4 out of 8 pipelines. Also the clock
is (in general....) the same.

Thomas

Ok, my bad
But besides 4 pipelines should be good enough, if you're on a tight budget.
You may get something better for 250Euro anyway. Even a 9800se but made by
saphire is better . Hercules cards are good and nice ( i'm using one myself)
, but don't overclock so good.

Your choice..


"Thomas" <thomas_@lycos.nl> wrote in message
news:hkHXb.548754$_x2.1223529@zonnet-reader-1...
> Asestar wrote:
> > Nr.1
> >
> > Hercules is Se card! mean, only128bit mem(apposed to 256bit), 128mb vs
> > 256mb, And Se is clocked slower than PRO.
>
> No, it DOES have 256 bit mem, but only 4 out of 8 pipelines. Also the
clock
> is (in general....) the same.
>
> Thomas
>
>