Overlord wrote:
> On Mon, 21 Feb 2005 06:12:55 -0600, David Maynard <> wrote:
>
>
>>Matt wrote:
>>
>>
>>>David Maynard wrote:
>>>
>>>
>>>>Nicholas Buenk wrote:
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>>"relic" <> wrote in message
>>>>>news:XztQd.2889$ ...
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>>Ted Campanelli wrote:
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>>What I find interesting is that monopolies are not legal in this
>>>>>>>country (US ). Where is the competition to Microsoft ?
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>There is no guarantee of Competition. Only that anyone _can_ start a
>>>>>>company or sell a product that competes. Why don't you?
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>It's very hard to develope a competing OS when so much depends on
>>>>>software compatablity. Sure, you can make a great technologically
>>>>>advanced OS, which won't likely do very well in the market because
>>>>>there will be no software to run on it.
>>>>
>>>>Patents are government inforced monopolies.
>>>>
>>>>That *is* the point of them: That he who invents it should reap the
>>>>benefit, for a period of time, of having done so.
>>>>
>>>>Why in the world should I spend the time, effort, and money to invent
>>>>something if you're going to just copy it for free? YOU go waste a few
>>>>million inventing it and *I'll* do the copying.
>>>
>>>
>>>Okay, but don't forget to patent it too
>>
>>Well, it *would* be rather difficult to talk about "Patents are government
>>inforced monopolies" if it wasn't patented, now wouldn't it?
>>
>>
>>
>>>---like Microsoft. Here is their
>>>patent (#6,727,830) on the mouse double click:
>>>
>>>http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-P...&RS=PN/6727830
>>
>>I'm not going to debate the virtues of individual patents since selectively
>>picking one to argue against the patent concept itself is like arguing
>>there should be no traffic laws because you dispute the merit of a 30 MPH
>>speed limit on Elm.
>>
>>
>
> I believe I will patent the concept of clicking with the left mouse button
> as opposed to the right mouse button. Then if you click with that finger
> you'll have to send me a nickel each time.
Good luck. But I think you'll find that getting a patent isn't quite as
easy as you seem to believe.
For one, you just told me, and on a public forum no less, which makes it
public domain. No patent.
Btw, I can't find any reference at all to a 'mouse' in the afore mentioned
patent. It's about "Time based hardware button for application launch" and,
in particular, "on a limited resource computing device" that is described
as "Small, mobile computing devices, such as personal desktop assistants
including hand-held and palm-type computers and the like." And the
"hardware button" is not a mouse key but the buttons on PDAs for launching
specific applications, as in "Therefore, as an alternative to launching
applications by using the stylus, the Palm-size PC contains a plurality of
buttons (called application buttons) that are used to launch the more
common applications installed on a Palm-size PC."