On Dec 30, 10:27*pm, Robert Myers <rbmyers...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Dec 30, 3:08*pm, Benjamin Gawert <bgaw...@gmx.de> wrote:
>
> > * Robert Myers:
>
> > > Most copies of Windows are sold under conditions that the license
> > > would be invalidated by changing the motherboard.
>
> > Please state the exact paragraph in the Ms EULA where it says that
> > changing the mobo invalidates your license.
http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20061102-8140.html
"OEM licenses still different
It bears repeating, however, the the OEM license that comes with Vista
is indeed similar to the Windows XP OEM license in that it forbids any
kind of transfer. As we have previously reported, users have
nevertheless had success transferring those copies of Windows, but
they are technically stepping outside of the bounds of the EULA when
doing so."
Retail licenses are transferrable, but they are a small fraction of
licenses sold. If you transfer an OEM license and get away with it,
it is, as I said, a matter of luck. If changing the motherboard
doesn't make the box "another" computer, that would be something for
lawyers to settle in court, not here.
Robert.
Besides the small fact that
> > such limitations would be against the law in most countries.
>
> "OEM" Copies of Microsoft windows are sold for use on one machine and
> can't (legally) be transferred to another machine.
>
> The question then becomes what constitutes another machine. *If you
> change enough hardware, the software believes it is on a different
> machine and thus, that the license has been invalidated. *It has
> always been my assumption that if you changed the motherboard without
> the software believing that it was installed on a new machine, it
> would only be a matter of luck. *That assumption could be wrong.
>
> In general, I'm not interested in responding to snotty demands that
> begin with "Please state the exact paragraph." *To copy your rude
> style, please cite the law that you believe would make Microsoft OEM
> licenses illegal. *Since you've said this is true for "most
> countries," I'm expecting a response with dozens of links citing all
> the relevant laws in different countries.
>
> Robert.