1. This forum section is a read-only archive which contains old newsgroup posts. If you wish to post a query, please do so in one of our main forum sections (here). This way you will get a faster, better response from the members on Motherboard Point.

review of X300 in warranty repair

Discussion in 'IBM Thinkpad' started by Cydrome Leader, Mar 8, 2011.

  1. The LCD bezel in my x300 cracked and the fingerprint reader has been dead
    for years.

    I decided to get it fixed before the 3 year warranty was up.

    Being in the US, the call went to Atlanta, and within minutes I had a case
    number, and an easyserv box in a day. The laptop was fixed an returned in
    just a few days.

    I'm going to rate the support with lenovo is as good as it was with IBM.

    That's good news. I think there's no question that my next laptop will be
    a thinkpad, yet again.
    Cydrome Leader, Mar 8, 2011
    #1
    1. Advertising

  2. Cydrome Leader

    News Guest

    On 3/7/2011 11:19 PM, Cydrome Leader wrote:
    > The LCD bezel in my x300 cracked and the fingerprint reader has been dead
    > for years.
    >
    > I decided to get it fixed before the 3 year warranty was up.
    >
    > Being in the US, the call went to Atlanta, and within minutes I had a case
    > number, and an easyserv box in a day. The laptop was fixed an returned in
    > just a few days.
    >
    > I'm going to rate the support with lenovo is as good as it was with IBM.
    >
    > That's good news. I think there's no question that my next laptop will be
    > a thinkpad, yet again.
    >
    >



    Good to hear this. Hope not to need it, but hope it's projectable.
    News, Mar 8, 2011
    #2
    1. Advertising

  3. "Cydrome Leader" <> wrote in message
    news:il4ao6$4sb$...
    > The LCD bezel in my x300 cracked and the fingerprint reader has been dead
    > for years.
    >
    > I decided to get it fixed before the 3 year warranty was up.
    >
    > Being in the US, the call went to Atlanta, and within minutes I had a case
    > number, and an easyserv box in a day. The laptop was fixed an returned in
    > just a few days.
    >
    > I'm going to rate the support with lenovo is as good as it was with IBM.
    >
    > That's good news. I think there's no question that my next laptop will be
    > a thinkpad, yet again.


    I don't blame you a bit. When I farkled my keyboard getting it out to
    upgrade the memory under it, I called IBM, they switched me to Lenovo, which
    I do believe was in Atlanta for my call as well, and I'd have had my
    replacement keyboard the next day if the DHL driver hadn't been an idiot.
    Keyboard and shipping, both ways, were free. And, I've already decided that
    my next laptop will be a ThinkPad, provided that they don't ditch the
    TrackPoint in the meantime. If they do, I'll have to think about it a bit.

    --
    -- 73 DE Tom Rutherford, N8EUJ, Burton, MI
    "She said it was either her or the ham radio. Over."
    Tom Rutherford, Mar 8, 2011
    #3
  4. Tom Rutherford <> wrote:
    >
    > "Cydrome Leader" <> wrote in message
    > news:il4ao6$4sb$...
    >> The LCD bezel in my x300 cracked and the fingerprint reader has been dead
    >> for years.
    >>
    >> I decided to get it fixed before the 3 year warranty was up.
    >>
    >> Being in the US, the call went to Atlanta, and within minutes I had a case
    >> number, and an easyserv box in a day. The laptop was fixed an returned in
    >> just a few days.
    >>
    >> I'm going to rate the support with lenovo is as good as it was with IBM.
    >>
    >> That's good news. I think there's no question that my next laptop will be
    >> a thinkpad, yet again.

    >
    > I don't blame you a bit. When I farkled my keyboard getting it out to
    > upgrade the memory under it, I called IBM, they switched me to Lenovo, which
    > I do believe was in Atlanta for my call as well, and I'd have had my
    > replacement keyboard the next day if the DHL driver hadn't been an idiot.
    > Keyboard and shipping, both ways, were free. And, I've already decided that
    > my next laptop will be a ThinkPad, provided that they don't ditch the
    > TrackPoint in the meantime. If they do, I'll have to think about it a bit.


    What I like about IBM/Lenovo is they don't try to waste your time (and
    theirs) trying to defer fixing a problem. Most of the parts that break on
    a laptop don't even cost more than a few dollars to replace. I'm sure
    shipping in the US costs more than the parts most of the time.

    I recall having to literally pull parts off motherboards to get dell to
    send out tek systems or whoever to replace completely unrelated parts like
    a CDROM because they just couldn't trust that I was able to diagnose a
    failed CDROM. The worst part was this was for business class machines for
    a business, not some $300 laptop. It was seriously easier to have a 100%
    dead machine than to get replacement parts shipped out. I felt like an
    asshole, but there was no way I was going to sit on the phone for an hour
    and waste another hour playing with the BIOS and stuff in windows.

    Sun microsystems has always been pretty meticulous about gathering "proof"
    a component in a server is really bad, but I suspect they really use that
    info in some secret database to make better products. It's been more than
    a few times they sent out real sun techs to replace parts that really only
    had bronze (mail order replacements you swap) coverage. Their bad parts
    forms you ship back with have hillarious codes you can fill in like
    "thermal event with smoke" and other great ways of saying your shit was on
    fire.

    I get the feeling that HP only cares if your server product has the
    rainbow hologram sticker on it. If you can come up with that, you get any
    new part you can think of, usually with no questions asked. If you can't
    get to that, say on a drive that's running inside a server 1000 miles
    away, they make a big deal out of everything and try to stall.
    Cydrome Leader, Mar 10, 2011
    #4
  5. "Cydrome Leader" <> wrote in message
    news:il9qvk$pvm$...
    > Tom Rutherford <> wrote:
    >>
    >> "Cydrome Leader" <> wrote in message
    >> news:il4ao6$4sb$...
    >>> The LCD bezel in my x300 cracked and the fingerprint reader has been
    >>> dead
    >>> for years.
    >>>
    >>> I decided to get it fixed before the 3 year warranty was up.
    >>>
    >>> Being in the US, the call went to Atlanta, and within minutes I had a
    >>> case
    >>> number, and an easyserv box in a day. The laptop was fixed an returned
    >>> in
    >>> just a few days.
    >>>
    >>> I'm going to rate the support with lenovo is as good as it was with IBM.
    >>>
    >>> That's good news. I think there's no question that my next laptop will
    >>> be
    >>> a thinkpad, yet again.

    >>
    >> I don't blame you a bit. When I farkled my keyboard getting it out to
    >> upgrade the memory under it, I called IBM, they switched me to Lenovo,
    >> which
    >> I do believe was in Atlanta for my call as well, and I'd have had my
    >> replacement keyboard the next day if the DHL driver hadn't been an idiot.
    >> Keyboard and shipping, both ways, were free. And, I've already decided
    >> that
    >> my next laptop will be a ThinkPad, provided that they don't ditch the
    >> TrackPoint in the meantime. If they do, I'll have to think about it a
    >> bit.

    >
    > What I like about IBM/Lenovo is they don't try to waste your time (and
    > theirs) trying to defer fixing a problem. Most of the parts that break on
    > a laptop don't even cost more than a few dollars to replace. I'm sure
    > shipping in the US costs more than the parts most of the time.


    Well, they *shouldn't* cost more than a few dollars, if you consider
    materials and fabrication costs, but some things with the genuine ThinkPad
    label on them can cost a lot more than the work-alike equivalent, and if
    it's not something that can be made by a third party, that will cost you,
    too. I'm thinking the keyboard was probably at least a $50 item, because it
    was specific to the R51 series. However, I bought an external CD/DVD burner
    with the Rosewill name on it that works with my ThinkPad just fine. I think
    I paid $30 for it, but an equivalent from Lenovo has a list price of
    probably $50 more. And, $50 for the UltraBay 2nd Hard Disk tray? If I
    could've found one for $20, I'd have still grumbled a bit, but I needed it,
    and got it. And, they price them that way because they can sell them at
    that price.

    > I recall having to literally pull parts off motherboards to get dell to
    > send out tek systems or whoever to replace completely unrelated parts like
    > a CDROM because they just couldn't trust that I was able to diagnose a
    > failed CDROM. The worst part was this was for business class machines for
    > a business, not some $300 laptop. It was seriously easier to have a 100%
    > dead machine than to get replacement parts shipped out. I felt like an
    > asshole, but there was no way I was going to sit on the phone for an hour
    > and waste another hour playing with the BIOS and stuff in windows.


    That's nuts.

    > Sun microsystems has always been pretty meticulous about gathering "proof"
    > a component in a server is really bad, but I suspect they really use that
    > info in some secret database to make better products. It's been more than
    > a few times they sent out real sun techs to replace parts that really only
    > had bronze (mail order replacements you swap) coverage. Their bad parts
    > forms you ship back with have hillarious codes you can fill in like
    > "thermal event with smoke" and other great ways of saying your shit was on
    > fire.


    LOL! Yes, I love the nomenclature of some of these companies. It's like
    faceplates. Most call them bezels, but GM, back when I was working on car
    radios in the early '70s, called them escutcheons. :) And, when did
    "problem" suddenly morph into "issue"?

    > I get the feeling that HP only cares if your server product has the
    > rainbow hologram sticker on it. If you can come up with that, you get any
    > new part you can think of, usually with no questions asked. If you can't
    > get to that, say on a drive that's running inside a server 1000 miles
    > away, they make a big deal out of everything and try to stall.


    Maybe they expect you to write somebody a note in your office, asking them
    to get hold of the owner of the building where your server is housed, and
    have him/her read the requisite data off the tag there. I gave up on HP
    when they boght Compaq. They used to make some bang-up good lab equipment,
    though, and for imaging technology, they're still top notch. Hate their
    drivers, though, at least for Winderz.

    --
    -- 73 DE Tom Rutherford, N8EUJ, Burton, MI
    "She said it was either her or the ham radio. Over."
    Tom Rutherford, Mar 10, 2011
    #5
  6. Tom Rutherford <> wrote:
    >
    > "Cydrome Leader" <> wrote in message
    > news:il9qvk$pvm$...
    >> Tom Rutherford <> wrote:
    >>>
    >>> "Cydrome Leader" <> wrote in message
    >>> news:il4ao6$4sb$...
    >>>> The LCD bezel in my x300 cracked and the fingerprint reader has been
    >>>> dead
    >>>> for years.
    >>>>
    >>>> I decided to get it fixed before the 3 year warranty was up.
    >>>>
    >>>> Being in the US, the call went to Atlanta, and within minutes I had a
    >>>> case
    >>>> number, and an easyserv box in a day. The laptop was fixed an returned
    >>>> in
    >>>> just a few days.
    >>>>
    >>>> I'm going to rate the support with lenovo is as good as it was with IBM.
    >>>>
    >>>> That's good news. I think there's no question that my next laptop will
    >>>> be
    >>>> a thinkpad, yet again.
    >>>
    >>> I don't blame you a bit. When I farkled my keyboard getting it out to
    >>> upgrade the memory under it, I called IBM, they switched me to Lenovo,
    >>> which
    >>> I do believe was in Atlanta for my call as well, and I'd have had my
    >>> replacement keyboard the next day if the DHL driver hadn't been an idiot.
    >>> Keyboard and shipping, both ways, were free. And, I've already decided
    >>> that
    >>> my next laptop will be a ThinkPad, provided that they don't ditch the
    >>> TrackPoint in the meantime. If they do, I'll have to think about it a
    >>> bit.

    >>
    >> What I like about IBM/Lenovo is they don't try to waste your time (and
    >> theirs) trying to defer fixing a problem. Most of the parts that break on
    >> a laptop don't even cost more than a few dollars to replace. I'm sure
    >> shipping in the US costs more than the parts most of the time.

    >
    > Well, they *shouldn't* cost more than a few dollars, if you consider
    > materials and fabrication costs, but some things with the genuine ThinkPad
    > label on them can cost a lot more than the work-alike equivalent, and if
    > it's not something that can be made by a third party, that will cost you,
    > too. I'm thinking the keyboard was probably at least a $50 item, because it
    > was specific to the R51 series. However, I bought an external CD/DVD burner
    > with the Rosewill name on it that works with my ThinkPad just fine. I think
    > I paid $30 for it, but an equivalent from Lenovo has a list price of
    > probably $50 more. And, $50 for the UltraBay 2nd Hard Disk tray? If I
    > could've found one for $20, I'd have still grumbled a bit, but I needed it,
    > and got it. And, they price them that way because they can sell them at
    > that price.
    >
    >> I recall having to literally pull parts off motherboards to get dell to
    >> send out tek systems or whoever to replace completely unrelated parts like
    >> a CDROM because they just couldn't trust that I was able to diagnose a
    >> failed CDROM. The worst part was this was for business class machines for
    >> a business, not some $300 laptop. It was seriously easier to have a 100%
    >> dead machine than to get replacement parts shipped out. I felt like an
    >> asshole, but there was no way I was going to sit on the phone for an hour
    >> and waste another hour playing with the BIOS and stuff in windows.

    >
    > That's nuts.
    >
    >> Sun microsystems has always been pretty meticulous about gathering "proof"
    >> a component in a server is really bad, but I suspect they really use that
    >> info in some secret database to make better products. It's been more than
    >> a few times they sent out real sun techs to replace parts that really only
    >> had bronze (mail order replacements you swap) coverage. Their bad parts
    >> forms you ship back with have hillarious codes you can fill in like
    >> "thermal event with smoke" and other great ways of saying your shit was on
    >> fire.

    >
    > LOL! Yes, I love the nomenclature of some of these companies. It's like
    > faceplates. Most call them bezels, but GM, back when I was working on car
    > radios in the early '70s, called them escutcheons. :) And, when did
    > "problem" suddenly morph into "issue"?


    haha "escutcheons"

    I just checked the sun "Global Part Return Tag FIELD SYMPTOM CODE TABLE"
    for the fire code. It's actually C10 "Thermal Event/Smoke Occured"

    The other codes I like are C5 for "Assumed good - please test", or C1
    "Wrong Part Right Box". These sound useful for the people at the parts
    remanufacturing line.
    Cydrome Leader, Mar 10, 2011
    #6
  7. "Cydrome Leader" <> wrote in message
    news:ilbj0g$aic$...
    > Tom Rutherford <> wrote:

    <big snip>
    >> LOL! Yes, I love the nomenclature of some of these companies. It's like
    >> faceplates. Most call them bezels, but GM, back when I was working on
    >> car
    >> radios in the early '70s, called them escutcheons. :) And, when did
    >> "problem" suddenly morph into "issue"?

    >
    > haha "escutcheons"


    Probably so that "civilians" can't order parts. :)

    > I just checked the sun "Global Part Return Tag FIELD SYMPTOM CODE TABLE"
    > for the fire code. It's actually C10 "Thermal Event/Smoke Occured"


    LOL! Wonder what they'd call it if a water pipe broke and flooded the room.
    "Aqueous Event"?

    > The other codes I like are C5 for "Assumed good - please test", or C1
    > "Wrong Part Right Box". These sound useful for the people at the parts
    > remanufacturing line.


    Well, the C1 could also refer to the right server in a particular colo being
    serviced, but the wrong part was changed out. C5 could be for the guy
    cannibalizing an old system, saving what parts he can.

    --
    -- 73 DE Tom Rutherford, N8EUJ, Burton, MI
    "She said it was either her or the ham radio. Over."
    Tom Rutherford, Mar 11, 2011
    #7
    1. Advertising

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

It takes just 2 minutes to sign up (and it's free!). Just click the sign up button to choose a username and then you can ask your own questions on the forum.
Similar Threads
  1. Kamal
    Replies:
    2
    Views:
    416
    Kamal
    Apr 21, 2004
  2. Kamal
    Replies:
    11
    Views:
    601
    Al Dykes
    May 17, 2004
  3. Replies:
    0
    Views:
    554
  4. Werner R Schilling

    Warranty on replacements under warranty?

    Werner R Schilling, Nov 5, 2005, in forum: Laptops
    Replies:
    10
    Views:
    423
    Barry Watzman
    Nov 7, 2005
  5. Justin
    Replies:
    0
    Views:
    562
    Justin
    Dec 26, 2009
Loading...

Share This Page